Rent-to-Buy Scheme: Pros, Cons and Tips


Ruth M & Local Insight

5/22/20232 min read

white and red wooden house miniature on brown table
white and red wooden house miniature on brown table

Explore the pros and cons of a Rent-to-Buy Scheme, including how rent payments build equity, addressing affordability challenges, and potential risks involved.

An increasingly popular approach to homeownership, rent-to-buy schemes offer a unique path for individuals to build equity in a property through rental payments. These arrangements offer a unique way for individuals to gradually build equity in a property through rental agreement while working towards eventual purchase. In this post, we'll investigate rent-to-own contracts arrangements to gain insight into how they work and their implications on accumulating equity and funds for purchase over time.

We will explore various aspects of rent-to-buy such as how your monthly extra rent can contribute towards building equity, credit history and the impact of property growth rates on accumulating sufficient funds for purchase. Additionally, we'll discuss the financial outlay involved in these contracts over time and compare them with traditional mortgages.

Addressing affordability challenges is crucial when considering a rent-to-own purchase arrangement, so we'll examine deposit accumulation through rental period payments and ways to reduce reliance on lenders' mortgage insurance. Furthermore, potential risks associated with these schemes will be highlighted along with recommendations for seeking legal advice before participating.

In the end, we'll help you decide if a rent-to-purchase setup is suitable for your needs by assessing your fiscal standing and ambitions in contrast to classic mortgage choices.

Table of Contents:

Understanding the Rent-to-Buy Scheme

The rent-to-buy scheme, backed by the Commonwealth Bank, offers first home buyers (rent-to-own property) an opportunity to break into the housing market. Participants pay rent, and 2.5% of that amount goes towards building equity to purchase the property eventually. If a property grows by 3.8% annually, enough equity should be accumulated within three to five years for participants to buy their own house.

How Rent Payments Contribute Towards Building Equity

In this innovative approach, a portion of your monthly rental period payments is allocated towards accumulating funds for purchasing the property at a later stage. This means that instead of paying rent without any long-term benefits, you are gradually working towards owning your dream home purchase (final purchase price).

Property Growth Rate and Its Impact on Accumulating Sufficient Equity

  • Growth rate: The success of this scheme largely depends on how well properties appreciate over time. If they grow faster than anticipated (e.g., above 3.8%), it will take less time for renters to accumulate sufficient equity required for buying their homes outright.

  • Achieving homeownership: On average, with consistent growth rates and regular rental payments made throughout participation in this program, aspiring homeowners can expect ownership within three to five years - significantly shorter compared to other traditional mortgage options available today.

Financial Outlay Involved in Rent-to-Buy Schemes

The rent-to-buy plan can be a desirable alternative for those who find it hard to amass enough money for a hefty down payment or abide by the conditions of regular mortgages. However, it is important to understand the financial outlay involved in such schemes before committing.

Total costs involved over a period of five years

For instance, let's consider a million-dollar house under this scheme. After five years, you would have spent approximately $411,000 on rental payments and savings towards your deposit (source). While this amount might seem significant at first glance, it could help those struggling with saving up enough money for traditional mortgage deposits.

Comparing financial outlays between rent-to-buy schemes and traditional mortgages

  • Rent-to-Buy: In the example above, after five years you would have contributed around $411,000 towards owning your home through rental payments and savings.

  • Traditional Mortgage: On the other hand, if you were able to secure a mortgage with a 20% deposit ($200k) on the same property without any assistance from such schemes - you'd still need to cover ongoing interest repayments along with principal reduction over time (MoneySmart Home Loans Guide). This could potentially result in higher price overall costs depending on factors like interest rates and home loan terms.

To make the best decision for yourself, you must consider both your current financial situation and long-term objectives. Rent-to-own agreements, rent-to-own contracts, and rent-to-own homes are all terms that refer to the rent-to-buy scheme. The rent-to-own purchase option involves paying monthly rent, which goes towards the eventual purchase of the property. The rent-to-own arrangement allows renters to pay rent and build home equity towards a future purchase. Lease-purchase agreements, and rental agreement are other terms used to describe the rent-to-own property. It's important to read the contract carefully and understand the terms of the lease-option contracts, lease term contracts, option fee, purchase option money, and other details of the Lease-purchase agreements.

While the rent-to-buy scheme can be a good option for some, it's important to consider the potential downsides. For example, if you can't afford the extra rent or the final purchase price, you may lose the option fee money and any home equity you've built up. Additionally, if the home prices in the real estate market decline, you may end up paying more for the property than it's worth. It's also important to consider your credit score and credit history, as poor credit or bad credit may make it difficult to secure a mortgage lender. Finally, it's important to ensure that the seller agrees to the eventual purchase and that you can afford the mortgage payments and property taxes once the lease expires.

Addressing Affordability Challenges

One major hurdle faced by aspiring homeowners is gathering enough funds for a deposit as well as lender's mortgage insurance costs. The new 'rent-to-buy' scheme aims at addressing these affordability challenges by allowing individuals to gradually build up their deposit through regular rental payments instead of needing substantial upfront capital.

Deposit Accumulation Through Rental Payments

The rent-to-buy scheme enables potential homeowners to contribute towards building equity in the property they are renting. A portion of each monthly rent payment, typically 2.5%, goes directly towards accumulating a deposit for purchasing the property in the future. This innovative approach allows participants to steadily save money while still enjoying the benefits of living in their desired home purchase. For more information on how this process works, check out this comprehensive guide on Rent-to-Buy or Rent-to-Own arrangement Explained.

Reducing Reliance on Lenders' Mortgage Insurance

Lender's mortgage insurance (LMI) can be an additional financial burden for those struggling with saving up for a large deposit or meeting other requirements of traditional mortgages. By participating in a rent-to-buy scheme and gradually accumulating sufficient equity over time, potential homeowners may reduce or even eliminate their reliance on LMI altogether when they eventually purchase the property outright. For more info on LMI and its implications, take a look at our article on Comprehending Mortgage Insurance from Lenders.

Potential Risks Associated with Rent-To-Buy Schemes

While rent-to-buy schemes offer several advantages for aspiring homeowners, they may not be suitable for everyone due to the inherent risks involved. It is crucial to understand these potential pitfalls before deciding whether this housing approach aligns with your financial goals and personal circumstances.

Uncertainty of Future Property Prices

A significant risk associated with rent-to-buy schemes or rent-to-own worth is gambling on future property prices. The success of this approach relies on the presumption that property values will remain constant and rise steadily, allowing participants to build up enough equity gradually. However, fluctuations in the property market can impact this growth and affect one's ability to purchase a home eventually.

Importance of Seeking Legal Advice Before Participating

Before signing a rent-to-buy agreement, it is wise to seek legal counsel from an experienced professional to avoid potential risks and ensure you are aware of the terms and conditions. A qualified solicitor or conveyancer can help you navigate through complex contractual obligations and protect your interests throughout the process. You can find more information about seeking legal advice by visiting The Law Council's website.

Evaluating Suitability for Rent-to-Buy Schemes

To decide if a rent-to-own works or is suitable, potential homeowners must assess their fiscal status and objectives in the long run (lease term). By considering factors such as current income, savings capacity, and personal preferences regarding property ownership or rental arrangements, individuals can make informed decisions about whether this innovative approach to housing will work best in meeting their unique needs.

Assessing One's Financial Situation and Long-Term Goals

Before committing to a rent-to-buy scheme, it is crucial to assess your current financial standing. This includes evaluating your income, existing debts, poor credit score, and overall ability to save money consistently. Additionally, consider how stable your employment status is likely to be over the next few years. Having clear long-term goals related to property ownership will also help you decide if this path aligns with those objectives.

Weighing Pros and Cons of Rent-to-Buy Schemes vs Traditional Mortgages

  • Rent-To-Buy Pros: You'll pay gradual deposit accumulation through rental payments; reduced reliance on lenders' mortgage insurance; easier entry into the housing market for first-time buyers.

  • Rent-To-Buy Cons: Uncertainty of future property prices; potentially higher price total costs compared to traditional mortgage payment; risk of unforeseen circumstances affecting finances during participation in the program.

  • Traditional Mortgage Pros: Potentially lower interest rates depending on credit score; more control over down payment amount; possibility of refinancing option money later on.

  • Traditional Mortgage Cons: Difficulty in saving for a large deposit; stricter lending criteria and requirements.

By carefully evaluating these factors, review the contract carefully, you may make an informed decision about whether the rent-to-buy scheme is suitable for your unique financial situation and property ownership goals.


Overall, the Rent-to-Buy Scheme offers a unique opportunity for individuals to accumulate equity and eventually own their home value. It is essential to assess personal finances and objectives before determining if this plan is the right choice.

While there are potential risks associated with rent-to-buy schemes, such as uncertainty of future property prices, seeking legal advice can help mitigate these risks. Additionally, addressing affordability challenges through deposit accumulation and reducing reliance on lenders' mortgage insurance can make this option more accessible.

Related Stories